Many Haitians Prospered in Springfield, Ohio. Then Came the Hate.

Sadrac and Gerda Delva found happiness again in Springfield.

After fleeing political corruption and violent intimidation in Haiti, the Delvas felt cocooned in the safety of the small Ohio city where they arrived in 2021 and rebuilt their lives.

The couple had steady jobs. Their young daughters were thriving. On weekends, the family of five visited nearby Buck Creek State Park and worshiped at a local church. They moved into what they thought would be their forever home.

“We were very comfortable here, thinking Springfield is our place,” Mr. Delva said in an interview, almost two years to the day since receiving the keys to a cream-colored, three-bedroom house.

It has been a month since former President Donald J. Trump and his running mate, JD Vance, injected Springfield into the election by spreading baseless rumors about Haitians abducting and eating pets. But many immigrants are still shaken, reordering their daily routines and reconsidering whether to stay where they feel unwanted and unsafe.

Members of hate groups have descended on Springfield several times in the last month. One group unfurled a huge banner outside city hall inscribed with “Haitians Have No Home Here” in English and in Haitian Creole. Ku Klux Klan fliers have popped up around town. A neo-Nazi group waved swastikas in front of the home of the mayor, Rob Rue, who has praised Haitians’ contributions while acknowledging the challenges created by the influx of new residents.

Most of the newly arrived Haitians are in the country legally, many of them granted what is known as Temporary Protected Status because of the widespread violence and instability in their homeland. Last week, Mr. Trump said that he would rescind Haitians’ Temporary Protected Status and deport them.

In the streets and stores, strangers have hurled insults at Haitians. The tires on their cars have been slashed overnight. Some shoppers have meowed at Haitians in supermarket aisles, according to Haitians, community leaders and immigrant advocates.

After hearing from friends who have been targeted, Mr. Delva, 43, said that he had no choice but to take precautions.

Gone are the afternoons at the park for his girls, ages 10, 5 and 2. Outings to Chuck E. Cheese have been scrapped. Even playtime in the backyard is on hold.

“Everybody is staying inside,” Mr. Delva said, except to go to school, commute to work or shop for groceries.

“I can’t remember the last time we went to church,” he said. “I talk to a lot of friends who are very scared, too.”

Thousands of Haitians have arrived in Springfield in the last few years. They have filled jobs in manufacturing, distribution and the service sector that were available after the city created a revitalization plan that attracted new businesses to the area.

Haitians are not the first newcomers to face hostility in Springfield.

In the early 20th century, the city drew poor southerners, white and Black, to work in factories. In 1904, a Black man was lynched and a Black neighborhood was set ablaze. Members of the Ku Klux Klan paraded through the streets.

White migrants were derided as backward people with “undesirable qualities of the new immigrant,” Max Fraser, a labor scholar, wrote in “Hillbilly Highway,” his history of Appalachian migration.

In the 1990s, Hispanics began arriving in Springfield and they, too, faced discrimination, said Jason Barlow, a representative in Ohio for United Automobile Workers, whose grandfather migrated to Springfield from Alabama in the 1940s. “It’s not the first time we see this animosity, unfortunately.” .

But the Haitians have been settling in Springfield at a moment when immigration has become one of the most contentious issues in the country, fueled by Mr. Trump, who has vilified immigrants and promised mass deportations if he returns to the White House. The influx of newcomers had strained government services in Springfield and had been fueling anxiety and tensions in the city, even before Mr. Trump used the presidential debate last month to stoke the debunked rumors of pet abductions. In the days that followed, Springfield faced a wave of bomb threats and Haitians encountered growing hostility from inside and outside the city.

“I haven’t seen hate rise to this level in my lifetime,” said Mr. Barlow, 50, who grew up in Springfield.

Mr. Trump and Mr. Vance have dismissed the outcry over the comments and instead have redoubled their attacks on Haitians in the United States.

In interviews, dozens of Haitians in Springfield said that they had fled their homeland to survive or to provide for loved ones living through the humanitarian crisis that has engulfed Haiti.

Nearly half of the country’s population is experiencing acute food insecurity, according to experts, and many have been forced to abandon their homes as gangs take territory. Last week, gangs rampaged through a town in Haiti’s main agricultural region, killing at least 70 people.

It is impossible to know how many Haitians have left Springfield because of the recent intimidation, but everyone seems to know someone who has relocated, or who is weighing that option.

Amanda Mullins, a real estate agent, said that Haitians who had saved as much as $50,000 to make down payments on homes have given up. One buyer backed out of a signed contract.

“Most everybody wants to wait,” Ms. Mullins said during a drive through northern Springfield, where she pointed to homes that she had sold to Haitians.

Lamarre Joseph, a 55-year-old teacher, and Charly Colin, a 41-year-old agronomist, share a two-bedroom apartment and work at a warehouse to support their families in Haiti. They were among those who said that they were contemplating leaving Springfield.

“We’ll find another city — Columbus, Boston, New York,” Mr. Joseph said. “We’ll go where there is opportunity.”

But for families with children, like the Delvas, Springfield is home. Even amid the fear and hate, uprooting is a tough option to consider.

The Delvas were financially secure in Haiti. They owned a home and two cars and traveled abroad on vacation. Ms. Delva worked as a biomedical technician.

“We never intended to leave Haiti,” Mr. Delva said.

Then their lives were upended.

Mr. Delva, an accountant, oversaw the disbursement of funds for a European charity.

In 2019, politicians began demanding that Mr. Delva give them aid to distribute to their constituents. When he resisted, Mr. Delva received threats on his life, which eventually spread to include his family.

Mr. Delva varied his route to work, and his wife and children limited their movements.. Armed assailants almost killed Mr. Delva when they accosted him in his car and opened fire.

By June 2020, the family had fled to Florida, where they applied for asylum.

They moved to Springfield after a friend told them that they would find good jobs, affordable housing and tranquillity.

“We started to work and save,” recalled Mr. Delva, who got a job working the overnight shift at an Amazon warehouse.

They began to love their life in Springfield and wanted to stay.

In 2022, the couple were expecting their first U.S.-born child. The Delvas made a down payment on a $152,000 house with three bedrooms on the north side of Springfield.

“We felt blessed, really blessed,” Ms. Delva said of their fresh start in Springfield.

She started a course at a local college to become a licensed nurse practitioner, and Mr. Delva studied and passed an exam to earn a real estate license. This fall, their middle daughter, 5, was so excited about starting kindergarten that she selected her outfits weeks before school started.

Then the rumor spread that pets were being eaten, disrupting everyone’s routine.

Mr. Delva said a Haitian friend was beaten up while walking to a Walgreens. There were bomb threats. White supremacists marched on the town.

“I told my wife not to go anywhere with the kids,” Mr. Delva said.

Mr. Delva has friends who have asked for transfers to other cities where their employers have branches. A few have already left.

“I think twice about leaving, of course,” Mr. Delva said. “I have three kids, I bought this house, my wife is studying.”

Asked how she liked Springfield, his eldest daughter responded, “Ten out of 10!”

Mr. Delva’s eyes welled up. “You cannot find words to explain the situation to children.”

Kitty Bennett contributed research.

Our Coverage of U.S. Immigration

• Court to Weigh Protections: A federal appeals court will hear arguments on DACA, which has allowed hundreds of thousands of undocumented young people to live and work in the United States.
• Changes to Asylum Restrictions: The Biden administration is expected to take action to make it harder to lift its policy banning asylum for migrants who cross the southern border illegally.
• A Wisconsin City’s Saga: Eau Claire had a plan. But opponents, mostly from rural areas, were convinced that the newcomers would destroy their Midwestern way of life.
• America’s Brutal Visa Lottery: For Chinese seeking educational opportunity, the United States has long been the top spot, but as more want to stay to work, their paths are full of roadblocks.
• A Migrant Family’s Struggles: Margarita Solito and her family fled violence and poverty in El Salvador, hoping to build a better life in San Francisco. The city often wasn’t what they thought it would be.